Saturday, September 19, 2009

Very discouraged

A few college situations are converging to make me feel like I don't belong at this institution any more:

-- continued student complaint about a borderline grade that I have absolutely no reason to cut student a break on: s/he got many, many breaks already during the semester -- my honest attempt to help -- but now I'm feeling as if I should never be "nice" to a student because it will bite me in the butt.

-- department discussion about online courses dominated by [insert adjective here] faculty who have a vested interest in increasing online offerings because the increase will line their own pocketbooks. These are faculty whose "pedagogy" consists of 1) worksheet-type exercises, mostly graded by the software, so they simply have to "design" a course and go the the cabin or of 2) lectures (called "discussions") about topics of interest to said faculty, never bothering to help students understand why such topics might be of interest to the students, who are simply a captive audience.

-- college-wide committee work that serves the programs relatively well but the general education (or "liberal arts") courses/programs very poorly. I've been sitting in meetings listening to colleagues say things like "why can't they think like us?" [okay, not exactly those words], and my [silent] response is, "because what you're doing isn't thinking."

I'm beginning to think our institution isn't about student learning -- defined by me as students actually grappling with the difficult developmental processes that go along with absorbing new information, figuring out how to solve problems that are new, attempting to think for themselves and then articulate that thinking in writing.

Given a new campus-wide initiative, we seem to be about "student retention" (make them happy by giving a good grade so they come back) or more simply "student tuition" (sign up for the classes, pay, and then you have a tiny window for changing your mind and getting your money back -- barely enough time to figure out what kind of class/experience you've entered).

When I first joined this faculty, the institution still had a bit of its old reputation as the premier liberal-arts two-year college, the premier transfer institution. That's gone.

When I first joined, I was eager to make this place a place I wanted to work: joined a ton of committees and initiatives; committed a bunch of psychic and emotional energy. I still do way too much, to a large degree. There's absolutely NO recognition of this kind of commitment by the faculty -- done almost exclusively by the female faculty for no extra monetary compensation of any kind (dollars or reduced course load). It's outrageous.

It's way too early in the semester to feel this way. But I'm about ready to let students pick their own grades, to let me classes out 20 minutes early every day and/or skip a day a week like many of my colleagues, to spend no time commenting on student writing (just slap a good grade), to quit the teaching part of my job. I can still do the entertaining, the one-on-one tutoring, the course design. But why do I really need to teach when it's not valued where I work.

Why?

4 comments:

Inside the Philosophy Factory said...

I hear your frustration -- and I tend to agree. I was told, by program folks, that the name of a course in MY discipline was somehow not an accurate reflection of the course... as if they knew. We were pretty much forced to adopt that name, or risk the wrath of the program folks...

I also decided that I would challenge my students and not worry about retention. I also declined to do late additions to the classes, as they don't tend to do well.

I think there are substantial things that can be done to improve retention, but I don't think there is the money, political will or the necessary set of cultural norms to support what really needs to be done.

julie said...

Your decisions mirror mine, the same ones I made when I started here eight years ago.

But this week, I'm worn out by the consequences of those decisions. The cultural norms have changed. It's so damn sad because this place once really did educate.

*Sigh*.

Now I get emails/phone calls from pals at the U of M who see one of our transfer students who's gotten an A in a writing class and can't perform at C-level. "What's happening over there??" he asks. "We depend on you guys."

Uh huh. Those days might be gone.

Kris Peleg said...

yikes. what's going on? the only piece I'm getting here is the discussion about online classes... and as you could see from the numbers I (risked) post(ing/ed), retention wasn't my priority.

julie said...

Kris ~ I'm just feeling worn out. The post you added about online courses fits with my knowledge, but the issue isn't retention. The issue is *who* teaches (and how they teach). that info isn't going to get into email.

The email exchange about Stefanie has also been getting to me: so many good intentions, but they're so not related to who she is/was.

And the dean's many conversations about a troublesome student just hit a maximum today, with two emails about it.

*Sigh*.

I'm getting some interesting testimonials on Facebook, though, from students (I sort of forget that I have my Century blog feeding to my Century Facebook account).

I'll get better, but today I'm feeling really, really underappreciated, peeved, and crabby.